07.05 Running a tabletop exercise
Create an AI-facilitated incident response tabletop exercise from your own risks, controls and policies, run it live with your team, and finalize an evidence-cited assessment you can keep as proof of testing.
Requires: Tabletop Exercise Extra
Tabletop exercises are run by the Tabletop Exercise Extra. Core SimpleRisk has no exercise facilitator, and an administrator has to activate the Extra before the Tabletop Exercises menu item appears.
Why this matters
An incident response plan nobody has rehearsed is a guess. Most frameworks and a lot of cyber insurance questionnaires ask you to test the plan on a recurring basis, and the usual way is a tabletop: a group sits in a room, a facilitator walks them through a made-up incident, and everyone says what they'd do. A good one takes an experienced person who also knows your business to write the scenario and then run it.
The Tabletop Exercise Extra plays that facilitator. It writes the scenario from your own risks, controls, assets, audits and policies, so the incident feels like yours. It answers questions during the session using the same records, and afterward it writes up how the group did against the objectives, citing what was actually said and decided.
Before you start
- Your administrator has activated the Extra and configured an AI provider.
- You hold the Able to Facilitate Tabletop Exercises permission to create and run an exercise. Everyone else needs Able to Participate in Tabletop Exercises.
- Know who will play which role. You assign people to roles before you start, and they need the participate (or facilitate) permission to be assignable.
One thing to understand up front: an exercise can draw on whatever you can see, narrowed to the data categories you tick. Participants then see scenario text and answers built from that data. Only tick categories you're comfortable sharing with the whole group.
Step-by-step
- Open Tabletop Exercises in the left menu and select New Exercise.
- Enter a title, the duration, a difficulty (Introductory, Easy, Moderate, Hard, or Extreme), and the data categories the exercise may use. Choose the incident response plan source: found automatically, from Incident Management, from governance documents, or none. Governance documents are read only when your account holds both Allow Access to "Governance" Menu and Able to View Documentation, and only the files attached to the documents themselves are used.
- Choose a mode. In Strict mode the controller answers only from your records and says "That is not known in this scenario" when it can't. In Improvised mode it may invent plausible details to keep the exercise moving, and those inventions are labeled Simulated and listed in the assessment. The mode is fixed for the whole exercise.
- Leave Build on my previous exercises ticked if you want new ideas to take your earlier exercises into account. SimpleRisk then avoids repeating a scenario you have already run and steers at least one idea back toward the objectives your earlier exercises rated Partially Met or Not Met, and the incident response plan gaps they found. It uses only your own finished exercises, up to your five most recent, and nobody else's. Untick it for a fresh start.
- Tick Blind Exercise if you want to play too. You won't see the scenario or what's privately sent to other roles.
- Select Create Exercise. SimpleRisk starts working out scenario ideas straight away and shows the exercise page while it does. After a short wait you'll see a few scenarios. Add steering text if you like and choose one. In a blind exercise, select Surprise Me.
- Review the generated objectives, roles and scenario steps. Edit any step's text and add or remove roles. Every role starts out played by the AI. For each role a person will fill, set Played By to Human and choose one or more people from the list, which follows your business unit when the Organizational Hierarchy Extra is on. Then select Approve and Open the Lobby.
- When everyone is ready, select Start Exercise. The group sees the first step, and you run the rest from the live room.
Managing your exercises
The Tabletop Exercises list shows every exercise you facilitate or take part in, with your role, when it was created and when it last changed. Click a column heading to sort, type in the search box to filter, and use the page-size menu and pager at the bottom for a long list. Select an exercise's row to open it.
Use the pencil on one of your exercises to rename it. The title is the only thing you can change after the exercise is created. Use the trash icon to delete one, or tick several rows and select Delete selected to remove them together. Deleting removes the exercise's scenario, session record and assessment, and it can't be undone.
In the live room
Everyone sees the current step, a shared feed, and a facts list. Some steps go to specific roles only; those show as Only Your Role, and the person who got one can use Share with the group to pass it on.
- Ask a question of the exercise controller. Answers cite the records they came from, or are marked Simulated. Tick Keep This Private and only you see the question and answer.
- Note what the group agrees. Notes are visible to everyone.
- On a decision point, each role commits one option, with an optional reason. The first commit for a role counts.
- On other steps, talk it through and use Ask and Note along the way. Before you move on, write down what the group concluded in the Outcome box and select Record Outcome. You can record several lines, and everyone who can see the step sees them. Then select Ready to Move On.
The exercise moves on by itself when everyone has tapped ready or every role has decided. As facilitator you can use Advance Now at any time. If you moved on too soon, Go Back returns everyone to the previous step. Nothing is undone: decisions already made stay made, and everyone taps Ready to Move On again. When you then move forward, SimpleRisk rewrites the next step to fit what the group did in the meantime. You can also Strike a fact you don't want treated as true, and End Exercise when you're done. Questions are limited to six a minute per person.
The assessment
When the last step is done and everyone is ready, SimpleRisk writes a short Wrap-Up for the whole group: a few paragraphs that tie the exercise together, with the main decisions, what the group agreed and what is worth carrying forward. It draws only on what everyone in the room saw, so private questions and steps sent to specific roles are left out, and it doesn't grade anyone. The facilitator can use Rewrite Wrap-Up for another version, or Write Wrap-Up if the first attempt didn't work. Then select End Exercise.
Ending the exercise starts the assessment in the background. When it's ready you get a draft with each objective rated Met, Partially Met or Not Met, the events that support the rating (the outcomes your group recorded count for the most), observations on each human role framed as strengths and opportunities, gaps in your incident response plan, questions the platform couldn't answer from your documentation, and every simulated fact. Private questions never appear in it. If a rating claims Met without supporting evidence, SimpleRisk lowers it for you and says so. Once you finalize the assessment, a PDF icon appears in the top right of the page. Select it to download the whole assessment as a PDF: the summary, each objective with its rating, rationale and supporting events, the observations on each role, the plan and documentation gaps, and the simulated facts. A draft can't be exported, because it can still change.
Change any rating or note, then select Finalize Assessment. Once finalized, it can't be edited, so it works as evidence that you tested the plan.
Common pitfalls
- Treating the ratings as grades. They describe the exercise and the process, not people. Say so before you start.
- Ticking every data category. More data doesn't make a better scenario, and it widens what participants can see.
- Using Strict mode on thin documentation. The controller will say "not known" a lot. That's useful (the gaps list tells you what to document), but pick Improvised if you want a smoother session.
- Switching a role to Human and not choosing anyone. A human role with nobody on it never decides, so the exercise waits for you to use Advance Now.